It’s REM, one of the most popular rock bands in the world, at The Olympia in Dublin, but they insist it’s “not a show”. What they mean is that it’s not an official concert. It is a show. That’s evident by the way Michael Stipe addresses the crowd; a selection of people with “impeccable” tastes. It’s a rehearsal show; a 2007 practice performance of songs from Accelerate and the tour that would presumably follow.

Fans of Around The Sun and Reveal might be disappointed with this album. The setlist, a special selection of the songs they performed, spends most of its time on the old stuff. There are six songs from Reckoning, for example, and five from Fables Of The Reconstruction, but none from Up, probably my favorite REM album. How cool it would have been to hear Sad Professor raw, unpolished and Jacknifed.

That’s a relatively minor complaint though. My major one is the talking the band does during some of the breaks, specifically the one that ruins the album’s conceptual flow; Stipe mentioning to his very appreciative audience that it’s the band’s “fifth” of five nights before magically going back in time to perform songs from the previous nights. With just that, this comes across as a random compilation rather than a proper set.

My favorite song here is Until The Day Is Done, which, like other Accelerators, had yet to been released. It sounds a lot like the album version though, unlike Disguised, which is a demo version of Supernatural Superserious. Other highlights include On The Fly; its absence from the Accelerate album baffles me; and Pretty Persuasion. I like the way Michael Stipe says the word “confusion” on that one.

my rating : 3 of 5

2009